solidoodle 3 lawsys x carriage left nema17

i upgraded my solidoodle 3 to a duet 2 maestro and my x axis was really noisy so i wanted to try a different stepper motor to see if it was the stock nema14 making all the noise so i decided to make the x carriage to mount a nema17 on there to try.
i first used the extruder stepper and that was worse then i used the z axis stepper and now its silent